Keyword      Search in       

Contact
Imprint
Site Map

GMP News
28 February 2008
 

FDA Guidance on Alternative Sterility Testing

 
The recently published Draft Guidance on Rapid Microbiological Methods (RMMs) for Sterility Testing of Cellular and Gene Therapy Products provides recommendations on the validation of growth-based RMMs in detail. It is the aim of the document to facilitate the implementation of an RMM for sterility testing.

Although this guidance has been designed for Cellular and Gene Therapy Products it is stated that “Some of the principles of RMM validation discussed in this guidance might also be applicable to products other than cellular and gene therapy products that are subject to sterility testing under 21 CFR 610.12.”

Apart from general recommendations on validation aspects (e.g. risk assessment, limit if detection, specificity, ruggedness, robustness) the document provides a comprehensive list of different categories of micro-organisms that should be included in the study:

  • Gram-negative bacteria

  • Gram-positive bacteria

  • aerobic bacteria

  • anaerobic bacteria

  • yeast

  • fungi

  • isolates detected in starting materials<

  • isolates detected by in-process testing or during preliminary product testin

  • isolates detected by environmental monitoring of your manufacturing facilit

  • isolates from your production areas which represent low nutrient and high stress environments

  • micro-organisms from commercial sources that have continually been exposed to high nutrient growth media

  • slow growing bacteria (such as Proprionobacter acnes)

  • fastidious micro-organisms for the RMM

  • micro-organisms reported in the scientific literature to be common isolates from a particular product type

This enumeration enforces the importance of including micro-organisms which belong to the natural habitat of the production facility and the product itself.
During the last years the trend towards using isolates for validation studies has increased significantly.

Furthermore, the document gives some helpful advice on designing a comparison study. Although the examples mentioned focus on cell-based products similar questions have to be discussed for other drug products, especially biopharmaceuticals.

Due to the short dating period of many cell-based products there is no convincing alternative to implementing RMMs for sterility testing.

Hopefully, this immanent pressure will leverage the use of RMMs also for other types of pharmaceutical products.

 

During the Biotechnology Session of ECA’s First European Microbiology Conference in Berlin, Germany, from 22-23 April 2008, alternative tests for the presence or absence of micro-organisms will be discussed by Dr. Thomas Montag, Head of Section “Microbial Safety”, Paul-Ehrlich- Institute, an agency of the German Federal Ministry of Health.


Author:
Dr Ulrich Herber
On behalf of the European Compliance Academy (ECA)

Source:
FDA Guidance for Industry “Validation of Growth-Based Rapid Microbiological Methods for Sterility Testing of Cellular and Gene Therapy Products” DRAFT GUIDANCE
http://www.fda.gov/cber/gdlns/stercgtp.pdf